This has been a monumental year for professional Counter-Strike in the worst way possible.
An unprecedented scale of cheating was uncovered as multiple coaches were using exploits during live matches to find information on opponents maneuvers in real-time, match-fixing accusations are at an all-time high while ESIC offers gentle taps on the wrist, the North American Counter-Strike scene is in disrepair beyond belief, stream-sniping during matches continues unabetted, and talent is dropping like flies.
Things are looking rough at the moment.
It should be noted that this isn’t necessarily the first time that CS has been on the back foot; Rainbow Six: Siege was hyped to be the Counter-Strike killer along with every title of the past two decades that has had a ‘competitive’ game mode wedged in somehow on release.
So this isn’t the end of Counter-Strike by any means of the term, but the road is currently rocky as all hell, and at the heart of it is the Counter-Strike Professional Players’ Association, typically referred to by their acronym CSPPA.
The CSPPA is a form of union that isn’t: it’s a player agency that acts like a union by consulting with players as to their feelings and ultimately refers to it as collective bargaining.
They had a hilarious power ranking that didn’t match any form of reality, they have allegedly cost tournament organizers hundreds of thousands of dollars, and now people are pointing at them for the consistent issues of Counter-Strike.
The issue appears to stem from the idea that the vast majority of CSPPA actions are not for the health of the Counter-Strike scene, but more so for their own lining of pockets and bullying organizations into what they believe to be a good idea.
This all begins quite a while ago, truth be told, as the CSPPA has butted heads with rumors being that the CSPPA’s mismanagement was causing untold damage with sponsors; recently, however, the fires have been reignited with fury on all sides.
with the CSPPA refusing BLAST voice comms of players along with video feed; this issue was brought up shortly after MIBR was caught (again) stream-sniping during a professional match; the next day, the CSPPA pushed out a strange statement.
Players refuse BLAST access to voice comms and video screen recordings without agreement on how information is handled pic.twitter.com/8RoofaQRA1
— Counter-Strike Professional Players' Association (@CSPPAgg) December 8, 2020
Some are alleging that the CSPPA is attempting to hide instances of stream-sniping from being recorded, and others are stating that it’s an entirely different issue altogether. The timing, however, was bizarre, as BLAST is attempting to use new organizational requirements to ensure competitive fairness.
I don't think you can. Asking to record the screen takes resources and there are other ways to do this (like recording the screen with a camera). Also having analysts listening to comms is a big no-no in all other tournaments.
— Antoine (@Costryme) December 8, 2020
Team Liquid then brought fourteen teams together (including themselves) stating that they’ve already talked to BLAST and that the TO had resolved the issues well prior to CSPPA even making a statement that tried to shut down the TO using video and audio from the players in a match.
On behalf of @Complexity @G2esports @natusvincere @NiPGaming @AstralisCS @EvilGeniuses @mousesports @furia @FaZeClan @TeamVitality @BIGCLANgg @OGesportsCSGO and @mibr pic.twitter.com/pbCVuJjIrj
— Team Liquid (@TeamLiquid) December 9, 2020
Cue speculation on precisely what in the world CSPPA is attempting to do; the timing looked strange enough, but to have multiple teams coming together and stating that the CSPPA is bringing up a non-issue for unknown reasons seemed to encourage speculation.
That speculation quickly turned on its head into a rampant fire.
For anyone interested what an evil marketing company pretending to be a player association's agreements look like. This was never about helping players, it was about making money and winning personal feuds with owners. I've been saying this since 2016 with the PEA letter. pic.twitter.com/qTqIfA0EIR
— Ryan Morrison (@Morrison) December 9, 2020
Ryan Morrison, the head of an Overwatch League player agency, has joined the fray and spoke directly about the CSPPA apparently owning every player.
Assigning over ALL ip, including their names, for a term of five years with no power to terminate for *any* reason. No attorney would sign off on this that I'm aware of.
— Ryan Morrison (@Morrison) December 9, 2020
Sadokist had a lengthy discussion with the organization on Twitter that resulted in fascinating results where the CSPPA claim to have worked directly with T2 players, yet none were to be found to verify the claims.
The lack of transparency, including where funds go, and how far the influence trickles outside of the interests of only the players within your memebership, as well as the motives of certain directors, is your downfall.
— Matthew Trivett 🐺 (@Sadokist) December 9, 2020
So the same players who have been seen to look after their own interests in a competitive game that relies on self preservation? You don't see a conflict with that?
Is there no charity initiatives? No scholarship funds? No contribution to up coming teams?
— Matthew Trivett 🐺 (@Sadokist) December 9, 2020
The fact of the matter is that without a set league system, nothing determines who qualifies as a member other than who you say… Which is where the issues begin. It's a control move. A cost breakdown should be the bare minimum of things you have to disclose publicly…
— Matthew Trivett 🐺 (@Sadokist) December 9, 2020
Look, cut the shit. You have the power to work in the benefit for everyone, but so far you've aligned yourself with profits in mind, and you aren't even using those to help the scene for EVERY player in mind. Get your shit together, wash your hands, and fix it.
— Matthew Trivett 🐺 (@Sadokist) December 9, 2020
How many T2 players have you talked to about their issues?
T2 is getting destroyed. NA players are struggling.
What're your plans to help the players who make 200 a month?
Nothing cause they can't help your cause?
I'm curious.
— Knights Seaside (@Keith_LaFortune) December 9, 2020
Thanks for the reply! I'm just going to ask a source.
@daveycsgo can you confirm this?
— Knights Seaside (@Keith_LaFortune) December 9, 2020
only thing I can confirm is that every team/player I've talked to below tier 1 and even teams in tier 1, have never been asked to vote on any decisions or elect representatives
— DAVEY 🇨🇦 (@DAVEYCS2) December 9, 2020
I’m in the CSPPA chat but nothing regarding my team or the NA scene has ever been brought up.
— Anthony (@Vanityxz) December 9, 2020
I remember when I talked to them when I made that tier 2 tweet or whatever when this all happened and the owner basically told me they have no power whatsoever and can't really do much for anyone :^) but said if they established the tier 1 scene, the rest would follow LOL…
— Jordan Montemurro (@Zellsis) December 9, 2020
The allegations regarding the CSPPA only looking out for themselves are piling up, and meanwhile, multiple members of the board seem intent on digging their graves as deep as possible.
Just gonna leave this here because you deleted it @chrisJcsgo. It's a non answer, doesn't actually address any of the perfectly reasonable questions @Sadokist raised. You are a representative for an organisation that is meant to care for all players… so start acting like it. pic.twitter.com/fif0ulNJpk
— Morgan "Novi" Palmer (@NoviCasts) December 10, 2020
The CSPPA believe that the NA scene had ‘died’, a sentiment echoed by Tarik of Evil Geniuses to heavy criticism. When the CSPPA believe a scene is dead, apparently they pull out all funding and resource allocation based on the beliefs.
Meanwhile, much as the community has been begging Valve to do anything regarding rampant cheating within the title (that they allege isn’t real), they’ve now begun requesting Valve to actually take control over the esport scene and stop the rampant allegations of collusion, the cheating debacles that drags the title through the mud, or to at least pretend to care about what was known as one of the strongest scenes in esports while others are reportedly looking out only for themselves.
Right Mr @CSGO, it’s time to get an esport coordinator to represent valve, I would put myself forward but I’m in a prime check stealing spot rn, so I’ll suggest @daveycsgo as a good candidate. I look forward to seeing the announcement sometime next week would be good
— ALEX (@CSGOALEX) December 10, 2020
Right now, it is not a clear picture of everything that is occurring, but a monumental storm is brewing and CSPPA seem to find themselves at the center while they believe that their beliefs should guide the entire course of COunter-Strike. A maneuver that is costing hundreds of people their jobs, and is likely not close to being done.
It’s punctuated repeatedly with statements that support trickle-down economics, where only T1 matters and everyone can receive scraps (as the CSPPA is filled with T1 only), outlandish statements regarding what regions they believe ‘deserve’ support while failing to strike for multiple players thrown wayside by archaic decisions that appear bear little wisdom for the scene as a whole.
Richard Lewis notes that the 2021 scene for professional Counter-Strike could be a very dark place, and we could be watching professional CS:GO actually kill itself.
This could be the beginning of the end. Decades of competition brought to an end because of greed and cheating, while fans somehow still support groomed personalities that actively participate in the disgusting behavior.